Showing posts with label detainee laws. Show all posts
Showing posts with label detainee laws. Show all posts

Monday, September 5, 2011

Should Terror Suspects Be In Law Enforcement Or Military Custody?

Photo from Reuters



New Bill Mandates Military Custody for All Terror Suspects -- The Atlantic



John McCain quietly inserted a provision in a Senate bill that would take away responsibility from law enforcement agencies like the FBI



A little-noticed provision of the National Defense Authorization Act would put all terror suspects into immediate military custody, a controversial change that would have significant legal repercussions for the ongoing war on terror.



The measure was tucked into the Senate's version of the omnibus Pentagon spending measure shortly before Congress adjourned for its summer recess. Similar language had been in the House version of the bill, but it was stripped out after intensive back-channel lobbying by senior White House and Pentagon officials. The measure's future will be decided when lawmakers from the two chambers meet in conference later this month to reconcile the two versions of the massive bill.



Read more
....



My Comment:
One more reason why the White House has a disdain for Sen. McCain. The WH prefers civilian authorities over military ones on this issue .... but this debate is coming back .... and in an election year at that.



What is my take .... I tend to lean for a case by case analysis and decision .... and only for crimes on U.S. soil. For actions overseas .... terror suspects should be in military custody.

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Why The U.S.S. Boxer Became A Floating Gitmo


Drift: How This Ship Became a Floating Gitmo -- The Danger Room

This is the U.S.S. Boxer. A big-deck amphibious assault ship, the “Golden Gator” displaces about 40,500 tons and provides a working home for more than 2,000 troops. Recently, its brig held a less likely passenger, Danger Room has confirmed: Ahmed Abdulkadir Warsame, a Somali whom the United States just charged with supporting al-Shabaab and al-Qaida in the Arabian Peninsula.

But if Warsame’s case is the future of terrorism detentions, that’s going to be a problem. The Navy simply doesn’t have enough ships with the brig space to serve as a floating Guantanamo Bay.

Read more ....

My Comment: Bottom line .... there is not enough room on these ships to house large number of detainees While it can probably accommodate a small number of detainees and only for a limited time .... it is definitely not a long term solution. Guantanamo has and still is the best way to handle these prisoners, but the administration clearly has a different altitude and direction on what to do with this facility.

Update: This Washington Times editorial nails it.

Monday, July 20, 2009

U.S. Expected to Miss Deadline On Detainee Policy

Journalists are escorted by military personnel Thursday to a court hearing for the five Sept. 11 attack co-defendants at Camp Justice, Quantanamo Bay. Associated Press

From The Wall Street Journal:

WASHINGTON -- Obama administration officials said they will miss a deadline to make recommendations on detainee policy -- a key part of the plan to close the prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, by January -- and are expected to seek an extension.

A White House official downplayed the missed deadline and said the January closure is still on track. Instead of a final report, the detention policy task force set up by President Barack Obama is expected to present him with an interim report on its work on Tuesday, administration officials said.

A separate task force reviewing individual cases of detainees, which affects the wider detainee policy review, expects to complete its review by October, an official said. The scope of the detention policy review goes beyond Guantanamo, dealing with how the U.S. handles future prisoners suspected of terrorism, and what to do with detainees who may require indefinite imprisonment without trials.

Read more ....

My Comment: As I had mentioned in previous posts .... this is all going to be done on a fly, with many of the key decisions being left at the end. And (I predict) the end result is going to be the following .... no one is going to be happy .... from the 9/11 families, military personnel, political opponents, and (more importantly) the majority of the American people.

Braeking Update: Gitmo review delayed 6 months -- Washington Times

My Comment: When I read the above Washington Times story .... I just shook my head. My colleagues and I have been predicting this for the past few months, so this announcement is no surprise.

But here is the bigger story .... an additional 6 months is still not enough.