Showing posts with label counter insurgency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label counter insurgency. Show all posts

Friday, August 20, 2010

A Latin American Perspective On Today's Counter-Insurgency Doctrine

Pictures of the missing in Argentina's Dirty War

Counter-Insurgency: From Latin America To Afghanistan -- Middle East Online

The US COIN program has its origins in the decades long US interventions - secretive and not so - in its own southern hemisphere. And the war in Afghanistan (and in Iraq) takes on the same state terror versus insurgent terror attributes of that long era of violence, notes Pablo Behrens.

In recent decades there have been only one or two precedents in which the United States and the United Kingdom could analyze directly the use of guerilla warfare by insurgents, and the response by government authorities. In the US' case it was the urban guerilla movement and the ‘threat’ of progressive political parties in South and Central America and the State terror it unleashed during the 1970s. In the case of the UK, it was the IRA mainland attacks of the 1980s.

Read more ....

My Comment:
Are the lessons learned from the 1970s-80s Latin American insurgency wars being applied to Iraq and Afghanistan? .... Pablo Behrens in his post clearly believes that they are .... and for all the wrong reasons.

Thursday, May 13, 2010

A Change In U.S. Counterinsurgency Strategy?

U.S. Army 1st. Lt. Harold Castweda, center, talks with an Afghan village elder about any improvements that can be made to a mosque in the village of Dubazai at Logar province, Afghanistan, May 9, 2010. Castweda is assigned to 173rd Brigade Support Battalion, which conducted a security check of the village. U.S. Army photo by Spc. De'Yonte Mosley

Pentagon Rethinking Value Of Major Counterinsurgencies -- McClatchy News

WASHINGTON — Nearly a decade after the United States began to focus its military training and equipment purchases almost exclusively on the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, U.S. military strategists are quietly shifting gears, saying that large-scale counterinsurgency efforts cost too much and last too long.

The domestic economic crisis and the Obama administration's commitment to withdraw from Iraq and begin drawing down in Afghanistan next year are factors in the change. The biggest spur, however, is a growing recognition that large-scale counterinsurgency battles have high casualty rates for troops and civilians, eat up equipment that must be replaced and rarely end in clear victory or defeat.

Read more
....

My Comment: After fighting in Afghanistan for almost 9 years .... and in Iraq for 7 years .... there is now a realization that the strategy is not working and the costs to continue are too high.

My prediction, the "new strategy" to be soon formulated and implemented will result in almost all U.S. forces out of Afghanistan within 2-3 years, and U.S. forces stationed in Iraq will remain in the desert where no one can see them (and be able to shoot and/or bomb them).

Thursday, April 2, 2009

The Rise Of Kilcullen And The COINdinistas

David Kilcullen

From Foreign Policy Blog:

An Air Force pilot explains why he found the rise of counterinsurgency specialists in the U.S. military over the last couple of years personally and professionally reassuring:

My love affair with the COIN community began when the dissidents took over the Iraq war, and I realized they actually knew what they were doing. After years of growing disillusionment with some of my leaders, I finally found a community of competent, intelligent military professionals I could trust. I can't overstate how important that was to me personally. Over the past year I've been drawn deeper and deeper into the COIN community. I follow its blogs, read its recommended books, and study the debates among of its members. The contributions of this community are extraordinary and I am constantly learning from it.

Read more .....

For more info: A Conversation With David Kilcullen -- Washington Post

My Comment: I am personally more focused on how new technology developments being introduced to the war theater can impact

Wednesday, April 1, 2009

Winning Counterinsurgency Warfare -- A Video


The speaker is retired Brigadier Justin Kelly of the Australian Army.

Hat Tip: Richard Fernandez at The Belmont Club