Showing posts with label commentary -- uav. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commentary -- uav. Show all posts

Sunday, March 24, 2013

Drones Everywhere

The Onion's fake photo shows drones flying over Obama's inauguration (The Onion)

When the Whole World Has Drones -- Kristin Roberts, National Journal

The precedents the U.S. has set for robotic warfare may have fearsome consequences as other countries catch up.

A slim aircraft glided through Israeli airspace, maintaining low altitude and taking a winding path to avoid detection. It flew over sensitive military installations and was beginning its approach to the Dimona nuclear reactor when it was blown from the sky by the Israel Defense Forces. The plane was pilotless, directed by agents elsewhere, and had been attempting to relay images back home. Whether they were successfully transmitted, Israelis won’t say, perhaps because they don’t know. But here’s what’s certain: It wasn’t American. It wasn’t Russian or Chinese. It was an Iranian drone, assembled in Lebanon and flown by Hezbollah.

Read more ....

My Comment: What was science fiction a few decades ago is now reality.

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Commentaries, Opinions, And Analysis On America's Drone Program

A U.S. Air Force MQ-1 Predator unmanned aerial vehicle, armed with AGM-114 Hellfire missiles, performs a low altitude pass. (Reuters)

The National Security Challenges That The U.S. Drone Campaign Can't Solve -- David Rohde, The Atlantic

Obama's excessively-secret targeted killing program has had plenty of unintended foreign policy consequences.

In President Barack Obama's bold second inaugural address, one line was my favorite. "We will defend our people and uphold our values," President Barack Obama declared, "through strength of arms and rule of law."

Obama was right to describe the "rule of law" as a weapon the United States can use to defend itself. But the administration's insistence on enveloping its counter-terrorism efforts in excessive secrecy flouts the rule of law. A proud American ideal is being turned into a liability, not an asset.

Read more ....



More Opinions, Analysis, And Editorials On America's Drone Program

When Can the U.S. Kill One of Its Own? (A discussion) -- New York Times
Where's the outrage over Obama's drone policy? -- Juan Williams, FOX News
As Neocons Defend Obama, Allies Doubt Him on Drones as Never Before -- Conor Friedersdorf, The Atlantic
What if it were Bush's drone policy? -- David Jackson, USA Today
Probing Obama's drone wars -- Al Jazeera
Detain: No. Kill: Yes. -- Juliet Lapidos, New York Times
The Targeted Killing Memo and the Problem of Secret Law -- Lincoln Caplan, New York Times
Obama’s ‘Just Trust Me’ Argument -- Andrew Rosenthal, New York Times
The Justice Department’s chilling ‘targeted killings’ memo -- James Downie, Washington Post
Obama’s drone policy, rooted in self-defense -- Michael Gerson, Washington Post
U.S. needs a rulebook for secret warfare
-- Jack Goldsmith, Washington Post
U.S. drone strike policy: Just War or just targeted killing? -- Susan Brooks Thistlethwaite, Washington Post
Indiscriminate Drone Warfare Is Wrong, Whether By Obama Or By Bush -- Eugene Robinson, IBD Editorial
Why Our Drone Warfare Campaign Is Right and Moral -- Mark McKinnon, Daily Beast
White House Drone Plan Reveals Obama's 'Hypocrisy' -- Jim Meyer, Newsmax
Assassin in Chief? -- Herbert W. Titus and William J. Olson, American Thinker
Actually, Obama's Drone Warfare Is Just What We Asked For -- Matt Lewis, Business Insider/The Week
About This "Legal Justification to Kill American Citizens" Memo -- David Weigel, Slate
A time to explain the drone campaign -- Washington Post editorial
A rightful airing of Obama drone policy -- Christian Science Monitor editorial
Drone Strikes Under Scrutiny
-- New York Times editorial

Wednesday, January 9, 2013

Drones Are Fueling A Global Arms Race

A soldier launches a Tier I Small Unmanned Aerial Vehicle "PUMA" during training at Schofield Barracks, Hawaii. Army

Experts: Drones Basis For New Global Arms Race -- USA Today

The success of U.S. drones in Iraq and Afghanistan has triggered a global arms race, raising concerns the remotely piloted aircraft could fall into unfriendly hands, military experts say.

The number of countries that have acquired or developed drones expanded to more than 75, up from about 40 in 2005, according to the Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress. Iran and China are among the countries that have fielded their own systems.

“People have seen the successes we’ve had,” said Lt. Gen. Larry James, the Air Force’s deputy chief of staff for intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance.

Read more
....

My Comment: The U.N. wants to now use them, and the Chinese and Japanese are rushing to have theirs. Bottom line .... the success of U.S. drones in Iraq and Afghanistan has triggered a global arms race .... and everyone is now rushing to catch up.


Saturday, December 8, 2012

Today's Drones Are Useless In The Pacific



Today's Unmanned Aerial Vehicles Will Be Totally Useless In The Pacific Theater -- Business Insider

The vast fleet of military drones the Pentagon has at its disposal will likely be worth very little in the Pacific, against more advanced, capable enemies, according to a report by Dave Majumdar of the site Flight Global.

"We are now shifting to a theatre where there is an adversary out there who is going to have a vote on whether I have that staring eye over the battlefield 24[hours], seven [days a week], 365 [days a year], and pretty certain they are not going to allow that to happen," says Gen Mike Hostage, commander of Air Combat Command, speaking at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS).

Read more ....

My Comment: It has always been understood that America's drone fleet is only effective against insurgents and a foe that does not have the means to shoot down high flying aircraft. Countries like China, Russia, etc., do have the means, and they will be effective in shooting down such aircraft. But these drones are just the first generation, and with time they are developing into better and more formidable instruments. At least that is the goal.

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

The Never Ending Drone War


The Long Third War -- Micah Zenko, Foreign Policy

No matter who wins in November, America should get ready for 10 more years of drones.

Nov. 3 marks the tenth anniversary of America's Third War -- the campaign of targeted killings in non-battlefield settings that has been a defining feature of post-9/11 American military policy as much as the conflicts in Iraq or Afghanistan.

Unlike other wars, there won't be any ceremonies at the White House or Pentagon, parades down Main Streets, or town square rallies to acknowledge the sacrifices made by the countless civilian and military personnel involved. There won't even be a presidential statement since targeted killings cannot and will not be recognized by the U.S. government. The war is conducted by both the CIA -- covert and totally unacknowledged -- and by the Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC) -- described without any specificity as "direct action" by the White House. Whether the CIA or JSOC is the lead executive agency, the Third War is marked by the limited transparency and accountability of U.S. officials.

Read more ....

My Comment: Not only should we be ready for 10 more years of drones, but an even greater escalation in the use of drones (and other robotic means of warfare) as research and development proceeds in the production of even more effective and lethal killing machines.

Sunday, October 7, 2012

What Does Israel Shooting Down A Drone Teaches Us About “Modern” Air Combat

Photo: U.S. Air Force F-15s fire missiles over the Pacific Ocean in an exercise. (USAF File Photo)

Israel Shoots Down Intruder Drone: What It Teaches Us About “Modern” Air Combat -- Washington Times

WASHINGTON D.C., October 6, 2012 – The Israeli Air Force released a video today which shows a missile homing in and destroying a small aerial object, presumably a drone, and another aircraft which appears to be an F-16 breaking away from the kill. According to Israeli authorities, the interception occurred around 10 am IST and was brought down around the northern Negev region after breaching Israeli airspace.

While suspicions abound over the origin of the intruding drone, U.S. policymakers should use this incident and its implications as a free case study for the growing trend of remotely piloted drones and UCAVs as America’s intelligence and combat aircraft of choice.

Read more ....

My Comment: A sobering assessment on what drones are capable now. But .... here is a prediction from me .... 20 or 30 years from now we will be scratching our heads and asking ourselves why would anyone want to fly in a manned fighter when drones are faster/more maneuverable/and have far more capabilities than a manned plane with all of the "biological limits" that a human operator will impose on it.

Tuesday, August 7, 2012

The Drone Culture

The Emerging ‘Drone’ Culture -- Eugene Robinson, Miami Herald/Washington Post

The age of the drones has arrived. It’s not possible to uninvent these Orwellian devices, but we can — and must — restrain their use.

As instruments of war, pilotless aircraft have already become essential. The Washington Post reported last year that more than 50 countries had developed or purchased drones to use in surveillance — and that many of those nations were working to weaponize the aircraft. Deadly missiles fired from drones are among the most effective U.S. weapons against the Taliban and al Qaida.

Read more ....

My Comment: Eugene Robinson hopes that the use of drones can be restrained .... I doubt that in today's world such a "hope" is even possible.

Monday, July 16, 2012

Making The Case For Using Drones

The Moral Case For Drones -- Scott Shane, New York Times

FOR streamlined, unmanned aircraft, drones carry a lot of baggage these days, along with their Hellfire missiles. Some people find the very notion of killer robots deeply disturbing. Their lethal operations inside sovereign countries that are not at war with the United States raise contentious legal questions. They have become a radicalizing force in some Muslim countries. And proliferation will inevitably put them in the hands of odious regimes.

But most critics of the Obama administration’s aggressive use of drones for targeted killing have focused on evidence that they are unintentionally killing innocent civilians. From the desolate tribal regions of Pakistan have come heartbreaking tales of families wiped out by mistake and of children as collateral damage in the campaign against Al Qaeda. And there are serious questions about whether American officials have understated civilian deaths.

Read more
....

My Comment:
The ability to spot, track, and observe a target for hours .... if not days .... and then "take them out" with a precision missile strike .... gives drones a leg up on everything else in America's arsenal. As drone technology improvements continue .... I expect this debate on drones will only intensify.

Monday, October 17, 2011

Fears Of Drones Are Unfounded

Photo: USAF

Unfounded Drone Fears -- Michael W. Lewis, Christian Science Monitor

America's use of drones has sparked fears of a new international arms race. But drones are surveillance and counter-terrorism tools; they are not effective weapons of conventional warfare.

Almost since the United States began using the unmanned aerial vehicles known as drones, their use has drawn criticism. The latest criticism, which has received considerable attention in the wake of the drone strike on Anwar Awlaki, is that America's use of drones has sparked a new international arms race.

While it is true that some other nations have begun developing their own unmanned aerial vehicles, the extent of the alarm is unjustified. Much of it rests on myths that are easily dispelled.

Read more ....

My Comment: The last sentence in this commentary is what caught my attention ....

.... It is important to recognize drones for what they are: slow, relatively low-tech anti-terrorism tools that would be of limited use on most modern battlefields and are particularly unsuited to use by terrorist organizations.

Drones may be slow and low-tech now .... but I suspect that 20 years from now commentaries like Michael Lewis will be singing a different tune.

Sunday, October 9, 2011

The Drone Arms Race

Coming Soon: The Drone Arms Race -- New York Times

AT the Zhuhai air show in southeastern China last November, Chinese companies startled some Americans by unveiling 25 different models of remotely controlled aircraft and showing video animation of a missile-armed drone taking out an armored vehicle and attacking a United States aircraft carrier.

The presentation appeared to be more marketing hype than military threat; the event is China’s biggest aviation market, drawing both Chinese and foreign military buyers. But it was stark evidence that the United States’ near monopoly on armed drones was coming to an end, with far-reaching consequences for American security, international law and the future of warfare.

Read more ....

My Comment: Drone technology is still in its infancy. While effective in conducting surveillance and attacking lone targets .... they still have a long way to go before being able to successfully attack fortified or heavily defended targets like carrier groups, command and control bunkers, and heavily protected military installations.

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Two Must Read Posts On The Evolving Drone Wars

The Air Force has experienced a UAV revolution since Sept. 11, 2001

9/11 And War On Terror Sparked An Explosion In UAV Technology -- Defpro

Hummingbird drones fly at 11 mph and can perch on windowsills. The 3-foot-long Raven can be tossed into the air like a model airplane to spy over the next hill in Afghanistan. The U.S. Air Force’s new Gorgon Stare aerial drone sensor technology can capture live video of an entire city. From the RQ-4 Global Hawk and MQ-1 Predator to considerably smaller aerial drones in recent years, the Air Force has experienced an unmanned aircraft revolution in the decade since Sept. 11, 2001.

Read more
....


A Hint Of Deterrence In U.S. Drone-War Strategy -- David Ignatius, Washington Post

Here’s the trickiest counterterrorism puzzle for U.S. policymakers: How do you stop al-Qaeda from attacking the American homeland without getting bogged down in protracted wars against insurgents?

One answer would be to establish deterrence in the long war against Islamic extremism, like the standoff that developed between the United States and the Soviet Union during the Cold War. The Soviets were obviously a far bigger adversary, but the basic logic is the same: Both sides have deadly weapons, but if you don’t shoot at us, we won’t shoot at you.

Read more ....

Thursday, September 22, 2011

The Use Of Drones Is A Supreme Court Case Waiting To Happen


Military, Police Drones May Lead To Supreme Court Ethics Fight -- Bloomberg

The large-scale deployment of drones by the U.S. military to track and kill enemies, as well as the use of the unmanned planes by police forces for surveillance, may lead to legal disputes about the rights to self-defense and to privacy, according to an article published today in the journal Nature.

The use of drones is “a Supreme Court case waiting to happen,” wrote Peter W. Singer, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, quoting an unnamed U.S. federal district court judge.

The U.S. Defense Department operates more than 7,000 aerial drones and 12,000 unmanned ground systems, Singer wrote, and the Miami and Ogden, Utah, police departments have sought licenses to operate surveillance drones.

Read more ....

My Comment: It is only a question of time before lawyers start to question past legal guidelines and decisions, and to apply them to today's legal and political world .... hmmmm .... I guess that time is rapidly approaching.

Our Growing Dependency On Military Drones


Drones Can't Change War -- William S. Cohen, Politico

Among the many issues that Defense Secretary Leon Panetta must ponder in the coming months will likely be whether to recommend shifting U.S. strategy in Afghanistan from counterinsurgency to counterterrorism.

Some critics argue that our current policy of deploying large numbers of ground troops puts more of our men and women at risk for questionable gain and even encourages more Afghans to join the Taliban, fighting against what they claim is an invasion force. Yet the recent gains in clearing out Taliban strongholds and helping to build schools, medical facilities and other civic institutions argue, instead, for staying the course for several more years.

Read more ....

My Comment: Another must read commentary on drones comes from David Ignatius at the Washington Post .... The price of becoming addicted to drones.

Update:
Drone dependency -- Abby W. Schachter, New York Post