Showing posts with label commentary -- cia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commentary -- cia. Show all posts

Friday, May 24, 2013

Is Now The Time To Shift The CIA Away From Drone Strikes?

C.I.A. to Focus More on Spying, a Difficult Shift -- New York Times

WASHINGTON — For more than seven years, Mike — a lean, chain-smoking officer at the Central Intelligence Agency’s headquarters in Virginia — has managed the agency’s deadly campaign of armed drone strikes. As the head of the C.I.A.’s Counterterrorism Center, Mike wielded tremendous power in hundreds of decisions over who lived and died in far-off lands.

But under a new plan outlined by the Obama administration on Thursday, the Counterterrorism Center over time would cease to be the hub of America’s targeted killing operations in Pakistan, Yemen and other places where presidents might choose to wage war in the future. Already, the C.I.A.’s director, John O. Brennan, has passed over Mike, an undercover officer whose full name is being withheld, for a promotion to run the agency’s clandestine service.

It is a sign that Mr. Brennan is trying to shift the C.I.A.’s focus back toward traditional spying and strategic analysis, but that is not an easy task.

Read more ....

Update: Obama to bring US drone programme out from 'legal shadows' of the CIA -- The Guardian

My Comment: The CIA became responsible for drone strikes because they became very good at it .... and they had the legal right to conduct this type of warfare that the Pentagon does not have. Is now the right time to make this shift .... I am not sure. I will defer to President Obama because he has intel that I do not have .... but if he is wrong .... he better be ready to suffer the consequences because Al Qaeda has proven in the past to be a very deadly organization .... and (hint hint) some of their key leaders are still around.

Friday, April 19, 2013

Should The CIA Be Responsible For Targeted Killings?

 

Should CIA Be Targeting Terrorists? -- Michael Hayden, CNN Contributor 

(CNN) -- On a hot summer day in early August, 2008, the secure Red Switch phone in my office at CIA was lighting up with calls from National Security Adviser Steve Hadley.

The Russian Army had invaded the Republic of Georgia in the Caucasus mountain region.

Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili was frantic about his country's safety and desperate for information on Russian forces and Russia's intent.

I promised Steve some answers, hung up the phone and walked to my outer office to direct my executive assistants to "get our Georgia people up here right away." As they busily dialed phones and typed e-mails, I remember turning to my chief of staff and only half jokingly asking him, "We've got Georgia people, right?"

Read more ....  

My Comment: The above video is a must see.

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Should President Obama Take The Drones Away From The CIA

Clip The Agency's Wings -- Micah Zenko, Foreign Policy

Why Obama needs to take the drones away from the CIA.

Among the 9/11 Commission's 41 recommendations was that "lead responsibility for directing and executing paramilitary operations, whether clandestine or covert, should shift to the Defense Department" to avoid the "creation of redundant, overlapping capabilities and authorities in such sensitive work." President Bush directed Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld and Director of Central Intelligence Porter Goss to review "to what extent implementation of the recommendation is in the interest of the United States." Goss -- himself a CIA operative in the 1960s -- told the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence: "[Rumsfeld] feels that he has capabilities that are important, and I agree. And I feel I have capabilities that are important, and he agrees. There's not a lot of disagreement on this."

Read more
....

My Comment:
There is a lot of meat in this analysis. As to what is my take .... I do not see President Obama giving all the authority of drone strikes to the Pentagon. The CIA has been very good at it's job (at least that is what they tell us) .... and if that is true .... President Obama may decide to not fix something that some of his closest advisers may believe is not broken.

How The CIA Transformed Into A Para-Military Organization

Cowboys and Eggheads -- Bill Kellerr, New York Times

My Times colleague Mark Mazzetti has a new book out that is getting a lot of attention, including some cinematic excerpts published in The Times, here and here. “The Way of the Knife” recounts the recent transformation of the Central Intelligence Agency from a traditional spying shop into more of a man-hunting paramilitary — custodian of lethal drones, sponsor of dark ops, employer of secret armies and shady contractors.

As an assassination bureau, the C.I.A. has had some spectacular successes. (The Navy Seal raid that killed Osama bin Laden was led by the C.I.A.) It has also come in for some fierce criticism from those who are uncomfortable with assassination in general, with the eerily impersonal methods of remote killing, with the civilian casualties, or with the timid oversight of an agency licensed to kill. And of course the demand for operational intelligence to aid these manhunts drove the C.I.A. into the practice of torture and rendition.

Read more
....

My Comment: The CIA stepped into this role of special operations because no one else was suited to do the job. There are also legal ramifications and guidelines that do not permit the military to do what the CIA now does .... unless the law is changed which I doubt that the White House and Congress will be willing to do. As to intelligence gathering and analysis .... this is now being conducted other agencies .... NSA, Defense Intelligence Agency, etc..

Friday, November 30, 2012

Is The CIA Headed In The Wrong Direction?

CIA Headed In The Wrong General Direction -- Roy A. Harrell Jr.

Agency should not be paramilitary force.

More than 50 years ago, my resignation from the Central Intelligence Agency was effectuated. The Company, as it had always been known, had become a bit too militarized and was not what some of its founders such as Allan Dulles envisioned.

Intelligence was collected but rarely analyzed coherently so as to contribute to enlightened policies. Much of what was collected by the Company lay unused, some of us feeling it is too expensive to collect this data, not to mention the risk involved.

Moreover the trend was in the direction of militarization, a task that could be more expertly done by the Department of Defense.

Read more ....

My Comment:
I know that the U.S. military has the means to do the job that the CIA is doing right now (i..e having a paramilitary force that can quickly execute certain operations) .... but aside from certain legal reasons on why the CIA is doing this work, I believe that the Oval Office and those who run the CIA like the ability (and option) to use the CIA in executing covert military operations and/or drone strikes against targets like Al Qaeda leaders. Is this the proper job for the CIA .... I do not know .... but they are doing the job and their masters (the politicians) appear to be happy with their performance.

Sunday, November 25, 2012

Why President Obama Should Not Appoint A General To Run The CIA

Why Generals Shouldn't Run The CIA -- Amy B. Zegart, Foreign Policy

As the Petraeus scandal unfolded, we got a crash course on the Tampa social scene, General Allen's superhuman ability to write 20,000 to 30,000 pages of "potentially inappropriate" e-mails, and the romantic attraction of the six-minute mile. What we did not get was a serious discussion of whether it was a good idea to let a warrior-general run the CIA in the first place.

The real Petraeus story is about much more than a seedy tabloid sex scandal. It's about what he did on the job — his brief tenure at Langley and the militarization of intelligence it represents.

Read more
....

My Comment: I have always been of the opinion that the reason why President Obama's chose General Peraeus to run the CIA was because he wanted a military orientation to the CIA. therefore .... my prediction for Petraeus' replacement will be someone like Petraues, but without the personal and emotional baggage.

Saturday, November 17, 2012

Will President Obama Rethink The CIA?

President Barack Obama delivers remarks during a memorial service at the CIA in Langley, Va., Feb. 5, 2010. (Official White House Photo by Pete Souza)

Time To Rethink The CIA? -- Walter Pincus

President Obama should pause before choosing a successor to CIA Director David H. Petraeus and rethink the role of the nation’s primary intelligence agency. Its main focus for the past decade has been fighting terrorists and insurgents.

The first question to ask: Has the CIA become too much of a paramilitary organization? The second: Should this be the time to put the agency’s main emphasis on being the premier producer and analyst of intelligence for policymakers, using both open and clandestine sources?

That doesn’t mean losing its counterterrorism role. Terrorists remain a threat, but the rest of the world is changing so fast that the president and policymakers down the line need the best information available.

Read more ....

My Comment: I suspect that such a debate probably happens every year .... wars and conflicts are always shifting. But will President Obama now take the opportunity to rethink the CIA .... I doubt it for the simple reason that the CIA as an institution is now exactly where he wants it.

Sunday, July 3, 2011

Attorney General Eric Holder Two-Year Investigation On CIA Misdeeds Come Up Short -- A Commentary

Attorney General Eric Holder Wasted A Two-Year Investigation On CIA Misdeeds That Never Happened -- New York Daily News editorial

A special prosecutor has dashed the fondest hopes of opponents of the war on terror by concluding that the CIA's program of so-called enhanced interrogations of Al Qaeda operatives after 9/11 was not shot through with criminality after all.

Investigator John Durham's finding confirms that Attorney General Eric Holder sent him on a wrongheaded mission in ordering a "preliminary review" of whether agents violated the law.

Read more ....

My Comment: No numbers published on how much this investigation cost .... my guess is that it is probably in the millions.

Thursday, April 28, 2011

How Prepared Is The CIA And Pentagon For The Next Crisis?


Will The CIA And Pentagon Be Ready For The Next Crisis? -- Fareed Zakaria, Washington Post

As Leon Panetta and David Petraeus move into their new jobs at the Pentagon and the CIA, they should use the occasion to fundamentally reorient U.S. intelligence and national security planning.

Consider the intelligence community. We spend around $80 billion on intelligence every year — more than the rest of the world put together — and yet we seem perpetually unprepared for global events. The CIA did not imagine the fall of the Soviet Union, the revolutions of Eastern Europe, the breakup of Yugoslavia, Sept. 11, Saddam Hussein’s nonexistent arsenal of weapons of mass destruction, the global financial crisis and, most recently, the Arab Spring.

Read more ....

My Comment: Governments have a long history of never being ready for the next crisis .... and I do not believe that this track record is going to change in the foreseeable future. What governments can do .... and I agree with Fareed Zakaria on this point .... is that governments should have their fiscal house in order, as well as some resources and monies "socked away" that can be used when a crisis does occur. But telling government to save money and put some aside instead of spending it .... LOL .... that is never going to happen .... especially with the current batch in Washington.

Sunday, April 25, 2010

Has Morale Returned To The CIA?

Leon Panetta Gets The CIA Back On Its Feet -- David Ignatius, Washington Post

CIA Director Leon Panetta has a new trophy in his seventh-floor office at Langley: It's the fuse from a Chinese-made rocket that he helped disable (with a CIA technician hovering close by) during a visit to an agency paramilitary training base.

That's a good metaphor for Panetta himself as he completes 14 months as CIA director. He has defused a number of bombs that threatened to blow up what was left of the agency's credibility, and in the process he has focused the CIA on getting the job done.

Read more ....

My Comment: My opinions on this matter are still mixed. While the CIA may now have more authority on going after Al Qaeda and other extremists, the worry of legal responsibility and accountability of past operations and methods still hangs over the many heads of its personnel.

Monday, August 24, 2009

Who Will Want To Work For The CIA After Today? -- A Commentary

Attorney General Eric Holder. AP

Prosecuting the CIA -- Wall Street Journal

Eric Holder unleashes a special counsel on U.S. war fighters.

'It would be unfair to prosecute dedicated men and women working to protect America for conduct that was sanctioned in advance by the Justice Department." –Attorney General Eric Holder, April 2009

"Justice Department Names Prosecutor to Reopen CIA Abuse Cases" –Wall Street Journal, yesterday


Mr. Holder had it right the first time. His about-face yesterday, compounded by his release of a 2004 internal CIA report on that agency's handling of terrorists, opens a political war that President Obama, the CIA and above all the country will live to regret.

This is a trap the Administration set for itself. Mr. Obama and his team have attempted to appease their political left by publicly denouncing the Bush Administration's national security policies, even as they claimed to want to forget the past. Their disparagement has only fed the liberal demand for Bush prosecutions and increased the pressure on Mr. Holder to appoint a prosecutor.

Read more ....

My Comment: I started a commentary on this last night .... having a good idea on what was going to happen today .... and after writing a long dissertation on why this CIA witch hunt was wrong .... I gave up.

One can argue on the legal aspects of the cases that the Special Prosecutor is going to investigate. The breaking of rules and regulations. The immorality of it all .... but I realized last night that it is not going to make one iota of difference.

Many in the White House have been gunning against the CIA for a long time .... Attorney General Holder being on of them. If it was not this case .... it would be another .... and trust me, the CIA is filled with cases and operations that can be scrutinized for breaking not only U.S. law but also the laws of other nations. This blog has chronicled numerous cases and operations that the CIA has conducted in just the past year .... and I say to myself .... "Is this legal?"

The continuous drone missile strikes and assassination attempts on Taliban/Al Qaeda targets in Pakistan. The raid on a Syrian Al Qaeda safe house on the Iraq border last fall that killed numerous Syrian civilians. Iraqi and Afghan ops that can fill a computer hard drive. The CIA is an organization with thousands of men and women .... and their one mission is to protect you and I .... and they do their best .... and their best usually results in someone suffering somewhere.

But this world is about to be turned upside down.

After today .... no one is now safe in the CIA and in the other U.S. Intelligence Agencies. Hundreds of people are now going to be subpoenaed by this Special Prosecutor .... and thousands more will always be wondering if they will be subpoenaed next.

This fear and worry will now grip most of the U.S. Intelligence community. The focus will no longer be to target Al Qaeda and their allies .... the focus will now shift to protecting "one's butt".

In such an atmosphere .... who will want to work for such an organization. To know that what is permitted and santioned by the political masters of today .... may put you in jail a few years later.

The politicization of intelligence has now begun .... and my guess is that the results are going to be messy and deeply divisive for the U.S. of A.

Monday, April 20, 2009

What Releasing the CIA Memos is Really About -- A Commentary

From The American Thinker:

It's realistic, not cynical, to assume political entities generally act out of their own self-interests. And political self-interests are what the CIA memos are really about.

The oldest declassified CIA memo is from 2002, the youngest from 2005. So one question is about timing. Why now? Another is about content. What do they offer that's new?

Read more ....

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Why Panetta Is the Wrong Man to Lead CIA -- A Commentary

From Pajamas Media:

On the morning of December 31, 1941, the flag of a four-star Navy admiral flew from the mast of the submarine USS Grayling in Pearl Harbor. It signaled the presence of Chester Nimitz, the former submariner who was assuming command of the U.S. Pacific Fleet.

The location of Nimitz’s change of command ceremony was symbolic for several reasons. Barely three weeks after the Japanese attack, most of the fleet’s capital ships were mired in the mud of Pearl Harbor, or en route to the West Coast for repairs. Admiral Nimitz later joked that the submarine was one of the few “decks” available for his ceremony.

Read more ....

Sunday, January 11, 2009

Let's Give the CIA Its Due -- A Commentary

CIA Memorial In The Lobby

From The Wall Street Journal:


Terrorists haven't been 'lucky' here since 9/11.

Richard M. Helms, the first director of Central Intelligence to rise from the ranks, was fond of saying that the CIA had been founded to make sure that there would never be another Pearl Harbor. Underlying this mission impossible was the wishful supposition that an America that knew everything could prevent anything. The CIA's job was to keep an eye -- a jaundiced eye -- on the whole world, friend and foe, weak countries and strong ones alike, as a means of preventing catastrophic surprises.

For more than 50 years, on the whole, the magic worked. And then, on Sept. 11, 2001, another Pearl Harbor happened. The CIA was not spared when blame was handed out. An intelligence failure had occurred and the result was the loss of 3,000 lives, billions in destroyed property, and incalculable damage to the American psyche.

Read more ....

My Comment: An excellent commentary. A must read for all.