Showing posts with label commentary - Afghanistan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commentary - Afghanistan. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 27, 2013

A Case For Nation Building In Afghanistan

U.S. soldiers provide security around an Afghan border police check point for traffic control on a major highway in the Spin Boldak district of Afghanistan’s Kandahar province, Feb. 21, 2013. The soldiers are assigned to Company B, 2nd Battalion, 23rd Infantry Regiment and Security Force Assistance Team 8, Texas Army National Guard. U.S. Army photo by Staff Sgt. Shane Hamann

How Not To Withdraw From Afghanistan -- Jim McDermott and Lawrence Wilkerson, Foreign Policy

Lessons from America's other war.

Eleven years of costly war have confirmed that there is no military solution in Afghanistan. As one U.S. commander in Afghanistan retires and another takes his place, it's time to focus on a political and economic transition to Afghan rule. It's time to finally bring U.S. troops home.

In his State of the Union address, President Barack Obama announced that 34,000 American soldiers, airmen, and Marines will indeed leave Afghanistan this year. But he provided few details about the withdrawal strategy. As he weighs the options for transferring security responsibility to Afghans and decides on what form the U.S. presence will take beyond 2014, he and his advisors would do well to remember the Iraq war as a cautionary tale.

First, the U.S. experience in Iraq showed that focusing too narrowly on a military solution comes at a high cost. The United States prioritized the buildup of the Iraqi Army, often at the expense of funding for crucial civilian programs in areas such as infrastructure support, governance and democracy, agricultural development, rule of law, and anti-corruption initiatives.

Read more
....

My Comment: An argument for nation building in Afghanistan even while a war is ongoing .... sighhh .... yeah right.

Monday, September 17, 2012

Is Afghanistan 'Facing Civil War When US Troops Leave'?

A U.S. service member assigned to Provincial Reconstruction Team Farah shares a laugh with villagers while conducting interviews during a civil affairs mission in Dizak village in Afghanistan's Farah province, Sept. 12, 2012. U.S. Navy photo by Lt. Benjamin Addison

Afghanistan 'Facing Civil War When US Troops Leave' -- The Telegraph

Afghanistan will slide back into civil war when American troops leave, according to a key insurgent negotiator who says peace talks now have no chance of success.

Ghairat Baheer, a senior figure in Hizb-i-Islami who has held three meetings with US officials in Kabul, told The Daily Telegraph that last week's decision by Hillary Clinton to declare the Haqqani network, an insurgent group linked to the Taliban, has killed off hopes of a negotiated settlement.

He said the withdrawal of US combat troops by the end of 2014 would leave Afghan forces ill-equipped to withstand the combined threat of insurgent groups.

"The Americans have their calculation that if it bring down expenses the lowest level but I don't think the national army and national police will be able to resist. They don't have the morale," he said. "It will lead to civil war."

Read more
....

My Comment: After 11 years of war .... billions spent .... thousands killed .... a U.S. withdrawal will only accelerate what has been the situation in Afghanistan for the past 30 years .... a continuation of sectarian and tribal strife and conflict.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Commentaries, Opinions, And Editorials On The War In Afghanistan -- March 27, 2012



Another Side Of Afghanistan -- Larry Towell, Time

Back in 2008, photographer Larry Towell’s agency, Magnum Photos, had contacted him about a project in Afghanistan that would require him to embed with the British military. Towell, having just completed work in Palestine, decided that he didn’t want to see Afghanistan for the first time with an embed, and instead set forth to see the country on his own. “It was important for me to learn more about the history of Afghanistan to get some perspective about what’s going on today and see if I even had anything to say,” says Towell, who was later awarded a Magnum Emergency Fund to aid his work. From 2008 to 2011, Towell traveled to Afghanistan five times, documenting in both photographs and videos the various social issues that plague its citizens, from drug addiction and poverty to the prevalence of landmines, many of which still remain from the Soviet occupation of the country during the 1980s.

Read more
....

Commentaries, Opinions, Analysis, And Editorials On Afghanistan

US defeat won’t be Afghan victory -- Pervez Hoodbhoy, Express Tribune
War Chief: Afghans Will Take Combat Lead Next Year -- Danger Room
Nato deaths raise tension over Afghanistan strategy -- Nick Hopkins, The Guardian
Rushing for the exits: The wrong lesson of A’stan -- Arthur Herman, New York Post
War Fatigue -- Mark Thompson, Time
Afghans do not want the tanks to leave, and nor should we -- Jillian Hocking, Sydney Morning Herald
O'Hanlon: My interview with General John Allen -- CNN
Kandahar massacre par for the course in Afghanistan -- Jean MacKenzie, Global Post
War Atrocities in Afghanistan: Who Is Blameworthy? -- Mark C. Russell, Huffington Post
Could we leave Afghanistan early? -- Juan Williams, FOX News
Who’s Going to Foot This Bill? -- Chuck Spinney, Time
Afghanistan and the long war -- George Friedman, Business Insider/Stratfor
How Would A President Romney Handle Afghanistan? -- Ari Shapiro, NPR
Obama’s ambivalent leadership on Afghanistan -- Michael Gerson, Washington post
Another Side of Afghanistan by Larry Towell -- Time
Afghanistan: Calm thoughts in hard times
-- Ronald E. Neumann, The Hill
US counts the cost in Afghanistan -- Alan Fisher, Al Jazeera
Time to cut our losses in Afghanistan -- E. Thomas McClanahan, Kansas City Star/McClatchy News
Civilian Massacres and Koran Burnings: A Tale of Two Misdeeds in Afghanistan -- Aryn Baker, Time
Analysis: Why the aid drawdown in Afghanistan could be a good thing -- IRIN
Robert Bales and the Twin Lessons of Afghanistan, 170 Years Apart -- Mort Rosenblum, New York Times
Britain's war cemetery in Kabul is a sobering reminder of our sacrifice in Afghanistan -- Con Coughlin, The Telegraph
Sustaining success in Afghanistan -- John McCain, Joseph I. Lieberman and Lindsey Graham, Washington Post
Don’t Stay the Course: A response to McCain, Lieberman, and Graham -- Andrew C. McCarthy, NRO
Charges in Afghan Shooting Will Be Start of Long Legal Journey -- Yochi Dreazen, The Atlantic

Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Ignoring The Real Strategic Issue On Afghanistan

Members of the Nagarhar Agribusiness Development Team, which includes U.S. troops, and members of the U.S. Agency for International Development meet with the owner of a hydro-electric facility for an inspection in Jalalabad City, Afghanistan, March 18, 2012. The agency's mission supports initiatives to ensure the sustainability of Afghan agricultural productivity. U.S. Air Force photo by Staff Sgt. Greg C. Biondo

The Next War In Afghanistan -- Washington Times editorial

Republicans ignoring the real strategic issue.

American troops will soon leave Afghanistan. What could become a key policy question for the 2012 election is, what will happen after they depart?

A series of new polls show that the public wants to wash its hands of Afghanistan. The trend was well-established even before recent anti-American riots and the massacre of 16 Afghan civilians, allegedly at the hands of Army Staff Sgt. Robert Bales. When Mr. Obama took office, a majority still believed that the war was worth fighting, but his lackluster performance in prosecuting the “war of necessity” has convinced them otherwise. An ABC News/Washington Post poll from the first week in March shows just 35 percent consider the war worth fighting, and 60 percent do not. A March Pew Research Center poll found similar results, with 35 percent saying the coalition should remain in force until the country is stabilized and 57 percent wanting forces pulled out now. A USA Today/Gallup survey concluded 24 percent wanted forces out by the 2014 deadline, and 50 percent wanted to speed up that timetable.

Read more ....

My Comment: The key points in this editorial. (1) The majority of Americans want US forces to leave Afghanistan. (2) The approaching civil war will be ugly, probably killing more people in the first year than in the past 10 years of conflict. And (3) if the wrong players persevere and win in Afghanistan .... U.S. forces may be dragged back into Afghanistan.

Former Soldiers Comment On Staff Sgt. Robert Bales' Alleged Massacre Of Afghan Civilians

Staff Sgt. Robert Bales checking identity papers during a training exercise at a mockup of an Afghan village at the National Training Center in California last August. The photo appeared in a military publication, High Desert Warrior. | U.S. Army

Former Lewis-McChord Soldiers Weigh In On Bales -- McClatchy News

Two former Stryker soldiers who've gone on multiple combat deployments and dealt with the trauma that can follow them offer divergent perspectives about whether such experiences could have played a role in Staff Sgt. Robert Bales' alleged massacre of Afghan civilians.

“It’s not shocking to me,” said Kevin Baker, a former staff sergeant with Joint Base Lewis-McChord’s 4th Brigade, 2nd Infantry Division. “There are hundreds, if not thousands, of soldiers who are screaming for help, but they aren’t getting it. And this was what, his fourth deployment? That’s pretty ridiculous.”

Read more ....

My Comment: What`s my take .... I cannot even imagine what was going through Staff Sgt. Robert Bales mind when he left the base and committed these acts. What I do know is that suicide rates, PTSD, drug and alcohol abuse, broken families .... this is going to be the American legacy of the Iraq and Afghan wars .... and as for Staff Sgt. Robert Bales`s and his crimes .... that will represent the worse part of America`s legacy in these wars.

Sunday, March 18, 2012

Repeating History In Afghanistan


Repeating Iraq’s Mistakes In Afghanistan -- Michael Kamber, The Good Men Project

War correspondent Michael Kamber paints a grim picture of the war in Afghanistan, which has learned nothing from the war in Iraq.

I left Iraq in January after covering the war on and off for nine years. Fortunate enough to be present at the withdrawal this past December, I learned many things in my years there. I have also worked in Afghanistan and, as I watch the news from there—the cold-blooded massacre of 16 civilians, the burning of Korans by American soldiers—I realize my painful lessons from Iraq are directly relevant to our current situation in Afghanistan. The most important of these lessons is the need for clear-eyed assessment and an end to what I term “magical thinking” on the part of American leadership.

Read more
....

My Comment: The best line from Michael Kamber's analysis ....

.... We must come to terms with the crucial fact that two opposing groups of fighters—taken from the same pool of Afghan men—are enormously divergent in their capabilities: those villagers that join the Taliban have fought the greatest army on earth to a standstill for a decade, those that join the US-trained Afghan army are incompetent, unmotivated and routinely turn their weapons on US soldiers.

Indeed.

Update: Michael Kamber has put together an impressive photo gallery of his work in Iraq and Afghanistan. The link to it is here.

Saturday, March 17, 2012

Afghanistan: How The 'Hell' Did We Get Here?

U.S. troops from the 101st Airborne Division survey the Afghan-Pakistan frontier from Paktika province, Afghanistan. Army photo/Spc. George Hunt

Afghanistan: A Gathering Menace -- Neal Shea, American Scholar

Traveling with U.S. troops gives insights into the recent massacre.

The soldiers around me were barely visible, but I could smell them. They had not washed for days, and a sharp musk of sweat and sleeplessness, tobacco and chemically mummified food, wove through the fields and orchards. It was after midnight, moonless, the stars brilliant but unhelpful. The soldiers wore night-vision goggles, but I did not, so I stumbled after their scent along the remote edge of a fading war, envisioning things I could not see.

Read more ....

My Comment: After finishing this article .... even if you may disagree with it .... you will have a moment where you will ask .... what the 'hell' are we doing there.

Is Alcohol A Problem On U.S. Bases In Afghanistan?

Photo from Adelaide Now

In Afghan Killings Case, Questions Over Alcohol -- Bloomberg Businessweek/AP

The U.S. military bans alcohol for its troops in Afghanistan, but that doesn't stop some soldiers from having a bottle or two stowed away in their gear -- a fact highlighted by investigators probe into whether alcohol played a role when a U.S. sergeant allegedly carried out a killing spree that left 16 Afghans dead.

U.S. investigators have determined that the suspect had been drinking alcohol prior to leaving the base the night of the attack, a senior U.S. defense official said Friday. How much of a role alcohol played in the attack is still under investigation, said the official, speaking on condition of anonymity because charges have not yet been filed.

Read more
....

My Comment: I hope that I am wrong .... but I suspect that drug and alcohol abuse is more rampant than what we are being told.

Friday, March 16, 2012

Can U.S. And Afghan Special Forces Salvage The Afghan War?

A coalition special operations forces service member defends his position from insurgent small arms fire during a firefight in the Sar Kani district of Afghanistan's Kunar province, March 7, 2012. A force of more than 100 Afghan commandos and coalition special operations forces searched an Afghan village for weapons caches and insurgents. U.S. Navy Petty Officer 2nd Class Clayton Weis

Can These Commandos Salvage The Afghan War? -- Danger Room

Part one of a two-part series.

LAGHMAN, Afghanistan — The American Special Forces officer was having what one colleague says was the worst day of his war tour. And that was before the Soviet-made anti-personnel mine packed with 700 ball bearings exploded at his feet.

A weapon like that can turn a man into “pink mist,” the officer says.

It was late September outside the town of Mehtar Lam, in this hilly province just east of Kabul. The officer from the Germany-based 10th Special Forces Group — let’s call him “Tom” — had been leading his patrol of U.S. commandos and Afghan police trainees on the long walk back to base following a disappointing encounter with Taliban fighters in which half of the trainees failed to fight back.

Tom glimpsed a mound of disturbed earth and, not thinking, approached it.

Read more
....

My Comment: What's my opinion .... I am not so optimistic. Afghanistan is a huge country with millions of people and a geography that is both harsh and forbidding. Throw in a few thousand U.S. Special Forces with a larger contingent of Afghan forces may tip a major battle or two .... but in the greater picture it will not have a significant impact on the war. Afghanistan's problems start from the top down .... corruption, tribal/religious differences, drug lords and Al Qaeda related groups .... throw into this mix the different Taliban groups who are dedicated to the overthrow of the Karzai government and couple this with the ingoing interference from Pakistan's ISI .... you cannot help but feel that it is impossible to get ahead.

Afghanistan has to be seen as a long term project .... a conflict that is going to last for decades and that will consume both blood and treasure at an alarming rate. But do we in the West have the will to last that long .... hmmmm .... no .... and .... quite frankly .... neither should we.

Saturday, October 8, 2011

Afghanistan War: A Decade Of Failure

(Click on Image to Enlarge)

A Decade Of Failure -- Frank Ledwidge, Daily Mail

After a decade of military operations in Afghanistan — the anniversary of the 2001 incursion falls this week — colossal expenditure and a rising death toll, the British are no nearer victory over the Taliban. Nor can they claim to have brought good governance and security to the region.

As I saw during a tour in Helmand as a civilian adviser, the British forces are now widely hated in Afghanistan because of this blood-soaked mess. Among Helmandis, Britain is largely viewed as a destructive foreign invader rather than the benign liberator of fashionable political rhetoric.

Even the Russians, who undertook the notorious invasion of Afghanistan in the 1980s, are far less despised than the British.

Read more ....

My Comment: A sobering assessment from one observer on the Afghan war. Read it all.

Saturday, October 1, 2011

Can We Still Win In Afghanistan?

U.S. Army Brig. Gen. Gary Volesky, left, talks to troops as they take a short break while on patrol near Wanat Village in the Waygul Valley, Afghanistan, Sept. 22, 2011. Volesky is the Combined Joint Task Force-1 and Regional Command-East Deputy Commanding General Maneuver, and the soldiers are assigned to the 25th Infantry Division's 3rd Brigade. U.S. Army photo by Pfc. Zackary Root

This War Can Still Be Won -- Fernando M. Lujan, New York Times

RETURNING home after 14 months in Afghanistan, I’ve sensed a growing gloom over the American war effort there. Many of the policy wonks, politicos and academics I encounter here seem resigned to failure.

While sipping their Starbucks, a few mutter the word “unwinnable.” They speak in grim sound bites: A gunfight on the United States Embassy’s doorstep. A helicopter shot out of the sky. But before people outside the Beltway accept this hardening conventional wisdom as fact, allow me to offer a different view.

Read more ....

My Comment: I do not share this "optimistic" point of view .... but it is still worth a read because it does give a slight glimmer of hope that not all is lost in Afghanistan.

Friday, July 1, 2011

Is U.S. War Strategy Working In Iraq And Afghanistan?

A U.S. Army soldier walks through a valley during a patrol through Malajat, Afghanistan, June 4, 2011. The soldiers are assigned to the 4th Infantry Division's Company D, 1st Battalion, 22nd Infantry Regiment, 1st Brigade. The purpose of the mission is to gather atmospherics from the local population and to distribute psychological operations products. U.S. Army photo by Sgt. Canaan Radcliffe

More U.S. Troop Deaths Raise Questions About Strategy -- McClathcy News

WASHINGTON — June was the deadliest month in nearly a year for U.S. service members in Afghanistan and Iraq even as the United States said that improved security in both countries allows it to reduce troops in those war zones.

Sixty U.S. service members were killed in the wars in June, from hostile and nonhostile incidents. The last time the United States lost that many troops in a month was last July, when 65 American service members died in Afghanistan and four were killed in Iraq.

Read more ....

My Comment: Every year the politicians and generals talk about forward progress on the ground in Afghanistan .... but every year the casualty rate for civilians, coalition forces, Afghan forces, and the Taliban increases substantially. 2011 is not going to be an exception, and I expect even more casualties as the withdrawal of U.S. and other coalition partners start this summer.

As for Iraq ... it is a different story. U.S. forces are no longer vital to the security of the Iraqi state (the numbers are no longer there) .... it is a role that is now being assumed by the Iraq army itself. Unfortunately .... Iraq has a long history of sectarian conflict, and I expect this conflict to continue when the last U.S. soldier has left. Because of this status .... the most important thing now for every U.S. soldier in Iraq is to not be that last soldier who gets killed in Iraq.

Thursday, June 23, 2011

Will President Obama's Afghan Withdrawal Decision Become A Disaster?

REMOVING TROOPS - President Barack Obama addresses the nation about the way forward in Afghanistan and his plan to remove 10,000 American troops from the country by the end of this year, with a total of 33,000 troops by next summer, at the White House, June 22, 2011. White House photo by Chuck Kennedy

Military Leaders Know Obama’s Decision Is A Disaster -- Robert Kagan, Washington Post

The press is reporting that the top military leaders have “endorsed” President Obama’s Afghan troop withdrawal decision. With all due respect to the fine reporters, that is not the news. Under our Constitution, military leaders have no choice but to endorse the president’s decision after giving him their best advice. They could resign, of course, but to have the entire senior military leadership resign over a president’s decision contrary to their advice would be a disaster, and not least for the troops on the ground.

Make no mistake, however. The entire military leadership believes the president’s decision is a mistake, and especially the decision to withdraw the remainder of the surge forces by September 2012. They will soldier on and do their best, but as the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Adm. Mike Mullen, put it, in characteristic understatement, they believe the decision will increase the risk to the troops and increase the chance that the mission will not succeed.

Read more ....

My Comment: I hope that the American generals are wrong, and President Obama is right. But for one retired general in Britain .... he has doubts.

What is my prediction .... Afghanistan will muddle on, and when U.S./NATO forces finally leave .... they will revert back to their old habits of warlords, religious extremism, and tribal conflicts. Will this be a disaster for us .... no .... but for the Afghans .... yes.

Friday, February 18, 2011

Why Afghans Don't Take The Taliban To Task For The Harm That They Do

An Afghan policeman inspects the site of a suicide car bomb attack in Khost province February 18, 2011. A suicide car bomb attack on a police checkpoint in eastern Afghanistan on Friday killed at least nine people and injured dozens, health and police officials said. The majority of the dead were civilians, among them three women, said Abdul Hakim Esaaqzai, chief of police for Khost province. Health official Amir Badshah said 30 people had been wounded and many taken to hospitals. Credit: Reuters/ Stringer

Suicide Bombings: Why Afghans Don't Take the Taliban to Task -- Time Magazine

It was carnage. There was a momentary crackle of gunfire and then, as a powerful car bomb detonated in Khost, a city in southeastern Afghanistan, a shock wave splintered trees and scattered body parts across 50 m of parkland and marketplace. Rags from what looked like children's clothes lay caught on the twisted metal of an axle; nearby, shops' windows were blown in, and the dirt road was slicked with blood. The iron strut supporting a giant billboard was bent like a paper clip.

Read more ....

My Comment: Why are Afghans not taking the Taliban to task for the carnage that their suicide bombings have inflicted on the general population was answered once by my father and from his own experience. The general population will never like innocent casualties as a result of a botched or catastrophic bombing done by a fellow countryman, but the foreigner is the one who will ultimately be blamed for the carnage. From their point of view, the foreigner does not belong there, hence, the focus becomes on what the local population must do to expel them out because they cannot expel their own countrymen who are fighting them.

My father`s experience came from the Second World War, and from what he learned about the Nazi occupation of Russia. Originally, many in the outlying Soviet states opened their arms to the Germans, but partisan activity, retaliation by the Germans .... all that good will was destroyed within a year. Within two years, it was wide open warfare. The mindset that the Russians had is the same mindset that many Pashtuns in Southern Afghanistan have today .... as bad as the Communists or Taliban may be .... they are our people. Foreigners are not.

In Afghanistan today .... let`s face it .... we are a 21rst century society mingling with a 8th century culture .... we are definitely the foreigner.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

What Is Success In Afghanistan















Defining Success in Afghanistan -- Small Wars Journal

Here's the video of Monday's Defining Success in Afghanistan panel discussion at American Enterprise Institute. I watched it live and thought it very informative and thought provoking - whether you completely agree with a particular view on the war or not.

The AEI-ISW report, which is the subject of this event, is available here.

Read more ....

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Decoding Obama's Comments On War In Afghanistan



Decoding Obama's Comments On War In Afghanistan: What Did He Really Mean? -- Christian Science Monitor

Obama’s citing of ‘fragile but reversible progress’ in his review of the war in Afghanistan is a signal to all the parties involved, including Americans, that the US withdrawal may go slowly.

A year after announcing 30,000 additional troops for the US-led fight in Afghanistan, President Obama offered a mixed picture of “fragile” progress and of more difficult days ahead in his annual review of the war.

Yet compared with a year ago – when Mr. Obama set the stage for the beginning of a troop withdrawal in summer 2011 – the president’s message on Thursday was more focused on the conditions that will determine the pace of a drawdown over the next four years.

Read more ....

My Comment: What is my take .... my gut tells me that President Obama wants to be out of Afghanistan ASAP. But to set the conditions for eventual withdrawal, he must give the image and perception that forward progress is happening in Afghanistan, and with this progress on the ground U.S. forces can (and will) eventually withdraw leaving the fate of the country to the Afghans themselves.

Interestingly, the Soviet Union did the same thing in 1988. They had their surge that forced the Mujaheddin to retreat to their sanctuaries in Pakistan. Declaring victory, Soviet forces then withdrew from the country leaving their allies in Kabul to handle the insurgency. Not surprisingly .... such a government did not last long.

Are we repeating history .... like I said before, my gut tells me yes.

Sunday, October 3, 2010

Why The Taliban Are The Greatest Enemy Force We Have Faced Since World War II

Photo: Different soldiers play by different rules. Does this make one better than the other? Possibly

Beards, Rags And Madmen - And The Art Of Good Soldiering -- Chris Ryan, The Daily Mail

Winston Churchill once said: ‘The first virtue in a soldier is endurance of fatigue; courage is only the second virtue.’

Our greatest wartime leader was rarely wrong. The ability to carry on when you are almost dead on your feet, to continue to hold your ground when others have faltered, is what, I believe, goes to make up a good soldier.

Read more
....

My Comment: There is very little that I disagree with here. To defeat an enemy one must approach such a conflict from multiple angles .... unfortunately in Afghanistan this is not being done. Safe sanctuaries in Pakistan, receiving aid and assistance from locals in Afghanistan, unreliable and ineffective Afghan forces .... sighhh .... from where I am standing the Taliban have plenty of time to recuperate, rearm, train, and continue the battle.

If our forces were not stretched and limited .... this war could easily go the other way. But with rules of engagement that limit our forces from fighting, manpower shortages to continue the fight. etc.... etc.... etc .... our ineffectiveness has resulted in us making the Taliban one of the most effective fighting forces that we have faced in a long time, and if trends continue .... they will win.

Saturday, June 5, 2010

Why Is President Obama Doubling Down On Afghanistan? (A Commentary)

SUNSET SCAN - U.S. Marine Corps Lance Cpl. Naoto Nakamura scans a village on the other side of a canal near Parghee Bagat in southern Afghanistan, May 31, 2010. Nakamura is assigned to Charlie Company, 1st Light Armored Reconnaissance Battalion. The Marines have been patrolling the villages and open terrain near Parghee Bagat to identify trends in the day-to-day lives of local Afghans. U.S. Marine Corps photo by Sgt. Dean Davis

Washington's Compulsive Gambling -- Tom Dispatch

History, or the future (however you want to look at it), has a funny way of rearing up and biting leaders who think they know what they’re doing. Take Barack Obama. Only weeks before the Deepwater Horizon oil rig exploded in the Gulf of Mexico, he made a “pragmatic” decision to give way on the expansion of deep-water drilling off U.S. shores in return for political support on his energy bill that might never have added up to much. In the process, he said on camera: “It turns out, by the way, that oil rigs today generally don’t cause spills. They are technologically very advanced.” His decision, which left the oil industry’s key lobbying outfit, the American Petroleum Institute, dancing for joy, doesn’t look quite so pragmatic or advantageous now.

Read more ....

My Comment: The reason why I like to read articles from Tom Dispatch is not because I agree with them (I mostly disagree), but because they make me think. This commentary from William Astore, especially his posting on "Doubling Down On Afghanistan", is an example of this and it is a must read.

Thursday, June 3, 2010

Who Has Time On Their Side In Afghanistan?

LAGHMAN MOUNTAINS - U.S. Army soldiers move through the mountains on a patrol to Kusuk village in eastern Laghman province, Afghanistan, May 24, 2010. The soldiers are assigned to Company B, 1st Battalion, 102nd Infantry Regiment. International Security Assistance Force members provided security, allowing civil affairs soldiers assigned to the Laghman Provincial Reconstruction Team to visit with villagers and discuss their needs. U.S. Army photo by Staff Sgt. Gary A. Witte

Time Is The Most Valuable Commodity On The Afghan Battlefield -- Times Online

War is a dirty word in Afghanistan. Mention it to a room full of American and British generals and you can expect frowns and the vigorous shaking of heads. At times it feels as though spin doctors have secretly infiltrated every coalition base, eliminated the commanders and put on their uniforms.

Instead of “offensives” and “assaults”, America and its allies now speak of war through euphemisms such as “activities”, “ongoing process” or “restoring order”. Operations are no longer called “Anaconda” or “Mountain Fury”, but “Together” and “Co-operation”. Detainees have ceased to be terrorists but misguided youths in need of an education and some vocational training.

Read more ....

My Comment: On June 7 of this month, the Afghanistan conflict will become America's longest war. Are Americans tired of this conflict ....from my vantage point I think they have been tired of this conflict for a very long time. With mixed signals coming from Washington .... coupled with a weak, corrupt and ineffective Afghan Government .... I know that my own patience on this war passed the breaking point a long time ago.

Wednesday, December 16, 2009

Two Must Read Commentaries On Afghanistan

U.S. Air Force F-16 Fighting Falcons conduct operations over eastern Afghanistan, Nov. 26, 2009. The aircraft crews are assigned to the 79th Expeditionary Fighter Squadron on Bagram Airfield. U.S. Air Force photo by Staff Sgt. Michael B. Keller

Fighting For The Dry, Mountainous Nothing In The Middle Of Nowhere -- Strategy Page

December 15, 2009: American commanders believe the 30,000 additional U.S. troops, plus increases in Afghan and NATO forces, will enable the Taliban to be crushed within a year. But after that, Afghanistan will require economic and military assistance for at least twenty years, to bring sustained peace to the country. The plan is to turn over security to the central government within five years. Initially, through the middle of next year, there will be more violence. The Taliban and drug gangs will not go gently into the night. They will resist energetically, many choosing to fight to the death.

Read more ....

A Stryker vehicle operated by U.S. soldiers sits on top of a hill overlooking Rajankala in Kandahar province, Afghanistan, Nov. 28, 2009. U.S. Air Force photo by Tech. Sgt. Francisco V. Govea II

Obama Commits More Troops To Afghanistan, With The Wrong Strategy -- War Is Boring

BARAKI BARAK, Afghanistan — The soldiers from Able Troop knew the attack was coming. Not only had they received several ominous warnings from some sympathetic local farmers in this agricultural district 50 miles south of Kabul, in mountainous central Afghanistan — they could also feel it in their bones. Some Afghan towns, on some nights, practically seethe with potential violence. Oct. 21 was such a night.

Read more ....