Showing posts with label afghanistan army. Show all posts
Showing posts with label afghanistan army. Show all posts

Friday, May 3, 2013

Is The Afghan Army Ready To Take Over?

An Afghan National Army soldier practices drills at an outpost in Maiwand District, Kandahar Province, Afghanistan, on January 29, 2013. (Andrew Burton/Reuters)

Afghanistan Is Not Ready To Take Over -- Richard H. P. Sia, The Atlantic

A special inspector general discloses that as U.S. forces head for the exit, the Pentagon has not met its goal for enlarging the Afghan force left behind.

Since the United States first sent troops to Afghanistan in 2001, a signature goal of the war has been to increase the size of Afghan national security forces and give their members the skills to vanquish domestic terrorist groups and other security threats on their own.

But as the Obama administration prepares to pull 34,000 U.S. troops out of the country by February and most of the remaining troops by the end of 2014, estimates of the size of the Afghan force trained to take over this lead security role have suddenly grown fuzzy and possibly unreliable.

Read more ....

Update: Audit casts doubt on number of Afghan troops U.S. has trained -- McClatchy News

My Comment: After analyzing and covering the Afghan war for almost 11 years .... I have learned that when it comes to Afghanistan nothing ever appears to be what Washington wishes it to be. In short .... our Afghan allies are not even remotely  ready, and this auditor's report is a red flag.

Thursday, April 25, 2013

More Doubts On the Afghan Army

Afghan Army Bruised by Long Battle -- Wall Street Journal

KABUL—New details about an ambush on Afghan troops in March and the army's stumbles in the monthlong battle that followed illustrate the challenges Afghanistan faces in taking over security around the country.

Afghan and coalition officials said recently concluded operations in the usually peaceful northeastern province of Badakhshan laid bare a range of problems faced by Afghan security forces throughout the country, from lack of advance planning and communication to inadequate supply and logistics.

What began as a simple resupply mission turned into a prolonged fight to reclaim a remote mountainous district. It also illustrated Afghanistan's reliance on coalition air power: In the final week of the operation, the Afghans had to call for backup from North Atlantic Treaty Organization aircraft—support that won't be available once foreign forces withdraw by the end of next year.

Read more
....

My Comment: Air support makes a huge difference in combat zones like Afghanistan. But this is the Afghan Achilles heel .... they lack such support.

Sunday, March 10, 2013

Afghan Women Head To Battle


Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Under Cover Of Darkness, Afghan Women Head To Battle -- NBC 

KABUL, AFGHANISTAN -- Severely outgunned, the battle was going badly. It seemed like certain defeat. Then, from out of the crowd stepped a young girl of around 14. She grabbed the pole from the fallen flag-bearer, held it up, and called out to her brothers-in-arms to fight to the death.

Though she was shot dead, her rallying cry was seen as the turning point of the 1880 Battle of Maiwand; a triumph for the Afghans, and a devastating loss for British forces during the Second Anglo-Afghan War. Her name was Malalai, Afghanistan’s Joan of Arc.

Read more ....

My Comment: I suspect that for these Afghan women soldiers the "front line" is everywhere .... and probably also within their own home.

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

The Afghan Army (Photo Gallery)

When the US withdraws its troops from Afghanistan in 2014, many wonder if the country's own forces will be able to hold the line against the Taliban and al-Qaeda. Helmand, November 20, 2012. John D McHugh/John D McHugh

Afghanistan: Holding The Line -- Al Jazeera

What are the challenges facing the Afghan army as it prepares to take over responsibility for the country's security?

As the 2014 withdrawal draws closer, and the US-led coalition prepares to hand power over to the Afghanistan National Army (ANA), filmmaker John D McHugh spent nearly a month in Afghanistan looking at the ANA's training in Kabul and in Helmand. What he found was an infantry army ready to fight, but a belief amongst those soldiers that they lack the equipment and logistics to hold the line.

WNU Editor: The photo gallery starts here.

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

The Secret Weapon In The Fight Against The Taliban Is .... Wooden Rifles

Raw: Afghan police recruits are put through their paces by their Western instructors while armed with wooden rifles.

Afghan Police Recruits Forced To Train With Wooden Rifles - After Shooting Themselves In The Foot (Literally) -- Mail Online

They might look a little wooden, but these are the latest police recruits being trained to maintain order in Afghanistan.

The raw trainees have no military experience and are not trusted with real weapons as they are put through their paces by Western instructors.

Recruits to the Afghan National Police (ANP) include farmers, shop owners and students and they are trained by the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) - formed by police officers from countries including Britain.

Read more ....

My Comment: In the Afghan culture, the AK-47 is a part of the furniture .... just as a Persian rug or Afghan tea. If these recruits are shooting themselves in the foot .... sighhhh .... something tells me that these recruits are at the bottom of the food chain in Afghanistan.

Monday, August 23, 2010

U.S. General Cites Ambitious Goals For Training The Afghan Military

New recruits for the Afghan National Army train at the Kabul Military training Centre September 29, 2009. Credit: Reuters/Ahmad Masood/Files

U.S. General Cites Ambitious Goals for Training Afghans -- New York Times

WASHINGTON — The American commander in charge of building up Afghanistan’s security forces said Monday that in the next 15 months he would have to recruit and train 141,000 new soldiers and police officers — more than the current size of the Afghan Army — to meet President Obama’s ambitious goals for getting Afghan forces to fight the war on their own.

The commander, Lt. Gen. William B. Caldwell IV, said the large recruiting number was to allow for attrition rates in some units of nearly 50 percent.

Read more ....

My Comment:
OK .... for the next 15 months Afghanistan will need to recruit and train 141,000 new soldiers and police officers .... and all of this with an attrition rate near 50%.

Yeah right ....

Update: If Afghan Troops Can’t Read Cat in the Hat, This War Is Screwed -- The Danger Room

Saturday, April 3, 2010

Searching For Good Afghan Officers

U.S. Army Gen. Stanley McChrystal, above, inspects an Afghan National Army guard of honor March 25 in Herat. Good leaders are "more important than equipment...more important than doctrine," McChrystal says. By Majid Saeedi, Getty Images

U.S. Looking For Leaders In Afghan Army -- USA Today

PUL-E-CHARKI, Afghanistan — Zakirullah Omid was a natural choice for a suicide bomber. The 15-year-old boy was young and an enthusiastic believer in the Taliban, having already committed brazen attacks against NATO and Afghan soldiers.

The Taliban visited his family one day and gave Omid a final assignment: blow himself up at an outpost commanded by Brig. Gen. Zemarai. The charismatic Afghan commander had been frustrating Taliban efforts in the rugged Tagab Valley, east of Kabul, and the insurgents wanted him dead.

Read more
....

My Comment: It will take years .... if not more .... for an Afghan officer corps to be developed and formed. The problem with such a program is that no one in the US (or any of our allies) has the patience or interest to stay in Afghanistan that long.

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Afghan Army Is Failing On Multiple Levels

Afghan National Army soldiers take cover behind a berm as U.S. Marines with 1/3 Charlie Company battle insurgents northeast of Marjah on Feb. 11. Patrick Baz / AFP via Getty Images

Afghan Soldiers Way Below Standard, Exasperated Marines Say -- McClatchy News

MARJAH, Afghanistan — If the U.S. Marines at Combat Outpost Turbett have any problems with their Afghan colleagues, they're with the Afghan soldiers who followed them into battle against Taliban fighters, not with the elite police officers who've stepped in to help fill the security vacuum.

While the Marines praise the Afghan National Civil Order Police force, they can barely conceal their contempt for the Afghan soldiers who live alongside the Americans in this one-time drug den in Marjah.

Read more ....

My Comment: This was the same problem that the Soviets had with their Afghan allies when they were fighting in Afghanistan in the 1980s. When the Soviets left .... it took only 2 years for everything to disintegrate.

It appears that we are repeating Soviet history. After 9 years of conflict, billions spent on training an Afghan security force .... we now have a dysfunctional and heroin addicted Afghan military.

If the Afghan soldier is unwilling to fight and protect his country .... why should we?

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

How Can The Taliban Pay Their Soldiers More Than What We Can Pay The Afghan Soldiers?



Winning Hearts And Wallets In Afghanistan -- CNN

(CNN) -- Two of the biggest goals for U.S. forces in Afghanistan are building up Afghan security forces and convincing Taliban fighters to lay down their arms -- and cash could come into play in achieving both.

U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates, who arrived in Afghanistan Tuesday on an unannounced trip, said money is a key reason why the Afghan government might be having recruiting and retention problems with its security forces.

Read more ....

My Comment: Am I the only one who sees something wrong here?

If this is true, I think it is our interest to know who is funding the Taliban, where are they receiving their monies and weapons, the intermediaries and arms suppliers, and what banks and institutions are facilitating their war.

My gut tells me that the military and the intelligence news agencies probably know the answers to these questions .... or have a good idea .... but for their own reasons are keeping it under wraps.

As to building up the Afghan Army (and the problems in this process), the New York Times has a good editorial on this topic here.

Update: Pay increase boosts applications for Afghan police -- Washington Post

Saturday, November 28, 2009

*Stoned* Afghan Soldiers (Warning: Colorful Language)



My Comment: This report was published at the beginning of this year. I am not sure if I had posted it before, but I saw it again today and decided to post it here .... another example of why the Afghan Government is going to lose in Afghanistan when NATO forces eventually leave.

Hat Tip: Rantburg.

Thursday, August 20, 2009

A Depressing Video (Another One) On The State of Afghanistan's Army



From The Captain's Journal:

The above video is yet another disheartening account of the complete lack of professionalism and seriousness of the ANA. The one mistake that the British forces made is in trusting the night watch (what the U.S. Marines would officially call Guardian Angel, but unofficially simply call ‘duty’) to remain awake without a Brit watching him and providing their own security. This was a huge mistake. There is more difficulty in getting the ANA to take the home searches seriously. General McChrystal’s edict disallowing ISAF forces from entering homes is problematic.

Read more ....

My Comment: When I see videos like this one .... I get that sinking feeling that we are going to be stuck in Afghanistan for years.