Showing posts with label Afghanistan aid. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Afghanistan aid. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 8, 2013

Why The U.S. Must Now Consider Withholding Vital Aid To Afghanistan

$50 Million In U.S. Funds Stolen From Afghan Bank Account -- Kevin Baron, Foreign Policy

Fifty million dollars in stolen U.S. funds that investigators had located in an Afghan bank account last year have suddenly gone missing while under the Afghan government's watch, according to a top federal watchdog.

The Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR) John Sopko made the stunning revelation in a scathing speech accusing the Afghan government of being a "criminal patronage network" from civil servant to the highest officials. Sopko, warning of an inept oversight of American taxpayer funds, claimed on Wednesday that the millions went missing after his office served the Afghan government an order to freeze the account.

"Briefly put, we identified roughly $50 million stolen from the U.S. government which was sitting in an Afghan bank account," Sopko said, in prepared remarks of a speech delivered at the New America Foundation.

Read more ....

My Comment: This is an outrageous story. Forget about withholding vital aid to Afghanistan .... just cut it .... but they won't. On a side note .... no wonder the U.S. and the West have a problem in Afghanistan .... if thieves can treat you with disrespect and go unpunished .... what message does that send to everyone else.

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

The Failure Of International Aid In Afghanistan

Local villagers receive humanitarian aid from the Bagram Provincial Reconstruction Team in the village of Nijrab in the Kapisa Province of Afghanistan Jan. 14, 2008. (U.S. Army photo by Staff Sgt. Tyffani L. Davis)

With Aid To Afghanistan, Past Performance Is A Predictor Of Future Returns -- Dan Murphy, Christian Science Monitor

A lot of aid to Afghanistan has been squandered. The latest project indicates that the US still doesn't seem to understand the country's basic needs.

In Afghanistan, it's not so much that the US is failing to learn from history. It's that it also seems to be failing to learn from the present.

During the past decade of war there, billions of dollars of US spending have been stolen, squandered, or have simply disappeared into well-intentioned projects that were inappropriate for Afghan needs.

So what is the US up to now? Planning more spending, even after US troops depart at the end of next year when it will have even less ability to monitor and account for spending than it does now.

This year the US is planning to spend $10 billion on Afghan "reconstruction" alone. While US plans for the country may begin to get some attention given the fight in Washington over slashing spending, raising taxes, or doing both, US plans for Afghanistan seem to be on auto-pilot. And some, frankly, seem utopian given its experiences there.

Read more ....

My Comment: Over the years I have been criticized (more than once) by a few individuals who work for aid agencies and who always felt that my analysis was too critical and pessimistic on the work that they were doing. OK .... I am not on the ground in Afghanistan .... so my analysis is limited .... but I keep on reading stories like the one above, and the money keeps on flowing into that country. Do I see any light at the end of the tunnel .... no .... and as the above Christian Science Monitor analysis clearly reveals .... do not expect any changes in the future.

Thursday, March 7, 2013

Squandering Aid In Afghanistan

Local villagers receive humanitarian aid from the Bagram Provincial Reconstruction Team in the village of Nijrab in the Kapisa Province of Afghanistan Jan. 14, 2008. (U.S. Army photo by Staff Sgt. Tyffani L. Davis)

$100 Billion In Aid Squandered in Afghanistan -- David Francis, Fiscal Times

The decision by the United States Agency for International Development to scrap the completion of a dam project meant to supply electricity to Kandahar, the spiritual home of the Taliban in Afghanistan, is the latest and perhaps largest failure of the United States to use development dollars to create stability by building Afghan infrastructure.

USAID had planned to spend $266 million to repair the Kajaki Dam, located in Helmand province, and to install turbines that would provide electricity to Kandahar City. More than 50 American soldiers were killed taking the area around the dam. USAID now plans to pass responsibility for installation of the turbines to the Afghan national power company, despite the widespread lack of confidence in Afghan government bodies.

Read more ....

My Comment:
I mentioned a few years back that even if $1 trillion in aid was pumped into Afghanistan .... ten years later there will be nothing to show for it. Bottom line .... as long as a culture of corruption, tribalism, and a lack of security with no rule of law is the norm in Afghanistan .... much of the aid that is brought into Afghanistan will be lost.

Thursday, January 31, 2013

How Afghan Aid Money Is Being Wasted Or Stolen

'Incalculable Waste' In U.S.-Paid $100 Billion Afghan Fund -- Washington Examiner

The unprecedented $100 billion program slated to rebuild war-torn Afghanistan has been ravaged by theft, cost overruns, bribes, unused facilities and "incalculable waste," and now the federal auditor of the reconstruction effort is urging Congress to make sure taxpayers are getting their money's worth before spending more.

But, warned an urgently written quarterly report to Congress from the Special Inspector General for Afghan Reconstruction, even if Congress gives the OK, auditing how Afghanistan spends the largest rebuilding fund in U.S. history will be difficult after American troops leave in October 2013.

Read more ....

My Comment: I have commented before that even if a trillion dollar Afghan aid fund was set up .... within a decade the money will be gone and there will be very little if anything to show for it. The culture of corruption, tribalism, sectarianism, and a long history of conflict are the root problems for Afghanistan. And while I do expect Afghanistan to one day rise from this mess .... it will do so on it's own terms and over a long period of time .... and $100 billion government aid packages will not expedite this process.

The Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction's website is here.

Thursday, January 24, 2013

How Billions Were Lost In Afghanistan

Afghan soldiers patrol during a security operation in Farah province, Afghanistan, Jan. 19, 2013. U.S. Marine Corps photo by Sgt. Chadwick de Bree

Money Pit: The Monstrous Failure Of US Aid To Afghanistan -- Joel Brinkley, World Affairs

More than half of Afghanistan’s population is under twenty-five, which shouldn’t be surprising since the average life span there is forty-nine. But the United States Agency for International Development looked at this group and decided it needed help because, it said, these young people are “disenfranchised, unskilled, uneducated, neglected—and most susceptible to joining the insurgency.” So the agency chartered a three-year, $50 million program intended to train members of this generation to become productive members of Afghan society. Two years into it, the agency’s inspector general had a look at the work thus far and found “little evidence that the project has made progress toward” its goals.

Read more ....

My Comment: The road to hell is always paved with good intentions .... in Afghanistan it has been expensive in both treasure and in blood.

Thursday, October 11, 2012

U.S. Ends 'Nation Building Program ' In Afganistan


U.S. Winds Down Afghanistan Aid Program -- Wall Street Journal

Military Pulls Out Development Teams That Had Been Central to War Strategy.

JALALABAD, Afghanistan—The U.S. military is ending a massive nation-building experiment in Afghanistan, shutting down teams that have poured hundreds of millions of dollars into roads, schools and administrative buildings in the country's hinterlands.

The shutdown, part of the withdrawal of U.S. and coalition forces over the next year, will mark the end of a hearts-and-minds campaign that has been central to the military's strategy.

As part of an effort to improve the reach and reputation of Afghanistan's central government, the U.S. and its allies set up over two dozen Provincial Reconstruction Teams around the country to dispense development aid and advise local officials. At least five of these have closed in recent months, and most of the remainder will shut down over the next year.

Read more ....

My Comment: Billions spent .... and very little to show for after 11 years of war .... I call this an admission of failure.

Monday, July 9, 2012

Afghanistan's Highway To Nowhere'


Afghanistan's Multimillion 'Highway To Nowhere' -- The Independent

New road is a white elephant, Foreign Office insider says

A flagship multimillion-pound highway linking Afghanistan's major cities is of no use to the majority of the population and at risk of crumbling during the winter, a secret report presented to British ministers has warned.

The 2,700km "Highway 1", largely bankrolled by American and Saudi millions, was seen as a symbol of Afghanistan's emergence as a modern democratic nation after decades of oppressive rule and conflict. But senior figures within the Foreign Office (FCO) have questioned the priority given to the project – and the standard of the finished road.

Read more ....

My Comment: Another depressing report on aid projects in Afghanistan.

Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Afghan Nation-Building Programs Are On The Brink Of Failure

STONE STEPS - U.S. Army Spc. Joshua M. McLay shows Afghan soldiers how to properly sight an M14 rifle during Operation Stone Steps at Nangalam Base in eastern Afghanistan's Kunar province, May 31, 2011. U.S. soldiers trained the Afghan soldiers on various marksmanship and weapons training throughout the four-day operation. McLay is an infantry squad designated marksman assigned to the 25th Infantry Division's Company A, 2nd Battalion, 35th Infantry Regiment, 3rd Brigade Combat Team. U.S. Army photo by Sgt 1st Class Mark Burrell

Afghan Nation-Building Programs Not Sustainable, Report Says -- Washington Post

The hugely expensive U.S. attempt at nation-building in Afghanistan has had only limited success and may not survive an American withdrawal, according to the findings of a two-year congressional investigation to be released Wednesday.

The report calls on the administration to rethink urgently its assistance programs as President Obama prepares to begin drawing down the number of U.S. troops in Afghanistan this summer.

Read more
....

My Comment: Someone has to do the proper research and documentation that explains how spending billions in aid programs will never succeed in a country whose cultural, political, and social structures exist in the 7th century while aid agencies are trying to implement a 21rst century model.

$320 million a month on foreign aid in Afghanistan, and very little to show for it. This is a disaster in the making .... and one that will guarantee a Taliban victory after Western forces withdraw in 2014. Fortunately, this realization is starting to hit Democrat senators, and I predict that as the Afghan mess gets worse, Republican senators will be on board by the end of this year.

Friday, January 15, 2010

U.S. Spending In Afghanistan Plagued By Poor U.S. Oversight

Construction of Afghanistan-Tajikistan Bridge. Photo from Wikimedia

From McClatchy News:

WASHINGTON — The U.S. has spent more than $732 million to improve Afghanistan's electrical grid since 2002, but delays and rising costs have plagued many of the projects in part because of poor oversight by the American government, a watchdog agency reports.

Of six projects under way in 2009, only one has been completed on time.

In the report released Friday, auditors with the Office of the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction blamed poor communication between U.S. officials and the two companies that are working on the majority of the projects.

Read more ....

My Comment: This is a surprise to me .... I thought there was no oversight. (I am being facetious).

Friday, July 31, 2009

How Aid Money Is Being Wasted In Afghanistan

The new buildings in this corner of the ancient city of Qalat were supposed to represent the U.S. commitment to creating a new Afghanistan. Back in 2006, the U.S. and other international donors spent more than $10 million to create what was meant to be a sort of Emerald City, just down the hill from Alexander the Great's ruined castle. (Nick Schifrin/ABC)

The Army's $10M Afghan Flop -- ABC News

Reversing a Failed U.S. Policy in Afghanistan

The new buildings in this corner of the ancient city of Qalat were supposed to represent the U.S. commitment to creating a new Afghanistan. Back in 2006, the U.S. and other international donors spent more than $10 million to create what was meant to be a sort of Emerald City, just down the hill from Alexander the Great's ruined castle.

A new hospital. A new governor's house. A fire station. A justice center. A visitor's center. A cultural affairs building.

Read more ....

My Comment: I am sure there are many more stories like this one that are not reported or covered.